Question by Christina: What is the difference in Full Metal Alchemist and Full Metal Alchemist 2009?
What is the difference in Full Metal Alchemist and Full Metal Alchemist 2009? Do I need to watch one before i watch the other? Which one is based off the manga more?
Best answer:
Answer by Valantino
By 2009 i take it u mean FMA brotherhood
the first one ending without the manga ending means that the manga is on-going
and it have nothing in comment to the 2nd one , its the same chars and stuff but with some differences
so it doesn’t matter which u watch first but dont think the 2nd is continuous to the 1st
its a re-make
the first one end with a movie , if u watched one and wanted to watch the other one then Dont compare then
the 2nd one is still airing , so if u dont want to wait for a ep every week then watch the first one till it air some more
Give your answer to this question below!
the first one is without the maga ending and the name is different
http://superspot.yolasite.com/
by 2009 you mean FMA – Brotherhood. FMA – Brother is made exactly like the manga. It has the same story as the manga. The first FMA has a few differences from the manga. For example in the first FMA, Roy Mustang kills Winry’s parents. But it’s different in the manga and in FMA – Brotherhood
Full Metal Alchemist was made during the time when Manga wasn’t written that far where anime makers can follow it thoroughly…It has many differences with FMA Brotherhood like many newer characters which were not in season one also season one s villain was a anime only character means that one was written for FMA season one only.
The Adventure of Elric Bros ended in 51 episodes and one movie named Conquerer of Shambala…This series has nothing to do with season two or with manga after 25 or 26th episode.
FMA Brotherhood is an remake of FMA(2003)and is based on manga completely so its an re-make but with different story after 15 episodes and also the creation of Humonculous in both season is different so watch FMA Brotherhood if u vent watched season one or watch season keeping this in mind that this is an anime with same characters and basic story but with different plots.
Full Metal Alchemist is the anime show that doesn’t follow the story of the manga and some characters from the manga doesn’t appear here, also some of the characters change their roles. Also this full metal alchemist has a movie entitled “Full Metal Alchemist: Conqueror of Shamballa” that is the continuation of this anime.
Full Metal Alchemist 2009 (or Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood) is fully based on the manga, the events, characters and roles are what you are reading in the manga (the manga is still ongoing). Some of the characters from the first full metal alchemist anime doesn’t appear here. You could say that Full Metal Alchemist 2009 is the original one that is exactly like the manga.
Fullmetal Alchemist was made in 2003/2004 when the manga was only a few volumes long, so they just took a few pieces of the manga/a few characters and twisted them into its own story.
(despite having an anime-original storyline and and an unbelievably long list of differences between it and the manga it’s actually really good, though)
Also, it was concluded by a movie called, Fullmetal Alchemist: The Conqueror of Shamballa
Fullmetal Alchemist 2009(FMA: Brotherhood) is the new series made to follow the manga nearly exactly…since the manga is now over 20 volumes and ongoing.
The first 13 episodes of it are a bit rushed because they were trying to hurry through the parts of the story that had already been somewhat animated in the first series(though the differences between the two versions are quite important)
You can watch either of them without even knowing about the other.
They share a few characters and a few bits of the storyline, but other than that, it’s two entirely different tales.